Unemployment and poverty is forcing 90% of South Africa’s 260,000 prisoners to commit crimes once released

South Africa's best employment website for online jobs / vacancies / recruitment

Work In South Africa - Job Seekers Premium Service

In a world grappling with the complex issue of recidivism, South Africa stands out as a country facing significant challenges. According to thought-provoking research, out of the prison population of roughly 260,000 at any one point in time, an alarming nine out of ten ex-offenders in South Africa reoffend, painting a bleak picture of the nation’s criminal justice system. However, a beacon of hope shines from an unexpected corner of the globe—Finland, where only one in three individuals released from prison return to a life of crime. This stark contrast begs the question: what sets these two nations apart in their approach to rehabilitation and reintegration?

A Deeper Dive into the Dynamics:

Delving into the intricacies of the criminal justice systems of South Africa and Finland reveals a myriad of factors contributing to their disparate recidivism rates. At the heart of South Africa’s struggle lies the state’s perceived reluctance or inability to address underlying conflicts within society, which serve as breeding grounds for criminality and fuel the cycle of reoffending.

Article continues below these Latest Work In South Africa Jobs:

Latest Work In South Africa Jobs

No jobs at the moment

One of the primary culprits is the pervasive issue of inequality, which creates fertile ground for violent crimes to take root. In a society plagued by poverty despite pockets of affluence, the disparity exacerbates the challenges faced by the marginalized and stigmatized. A serious lack of jobs in South Africa further compounds the problem, leaving many individuals disillusioned and vulnerable to criminal subcultures. These systemic issues, coupled with the state’s failure to ensure citizen safety and the exploitation of crime-related rhetoric by politicians, have perpetuated a stigmatizing shaming culture that alienates ex-offenders and hinders their reintegration into mainstream society.

However, Finland, a liberal democracy with its own unique set of challenges, showcases a different approach—one that holds valuable lessons for South Africa’s Department of Correctional Services. Despite sharing a stigmatizing shaming culture with South Africa, Finland has managed to achieve an admirable recidivism rate of approximately 31%. How has Finland succeeded where others have faltered?

The Finnish Model and Key Lessons:

An in-depth analysis of Finland’s criminal justice system reveals key features that contribute to its success in reducing recidivism. These insights can serve as a guiding light for South Africa’s pursuit of effective rehabilitation and reintegration strategies.

Firstly, Finland views punishment as the loss of liberty rather than subjecting prisoners to degrading or torturous conditions. Unlike South Africa, where practices such as solitary confinement and forfeiture of privileges persist, Finland strives to promote normalcy within its prison environment. This humane approach fosters a sense of dignity among prisoners, which, in turn, aids their integration into society upon release.

Secondly, Finland places a strong emphasis on reintegration. The country endeavors to provide ex-offenders with employment opportunities and other essential measures that facilitate their transition back into mainstream society. By addressing the basic human needs of offenders, Finland eliminates a primary source of conflict and empowers individuals to rebuild their lives.

Additionally, Finland’s prison system operates with a remarkable responsiveness to the concerns of prisoners. This approach encourages offenders to feel a sense of inclusion within the system, breaking down their resistance to cooperation with authorities. By understanding and addressing their problems, Finland bridges the gap between ex-offenders and the wider society, promoting a more seamless reintegration process.

Unveiling the Hidden Connections:

To understand the efficacy of Finland’s approach, it is essential to explore the historical and cultural factors that shape the country’s outlook on incarceration. African countries such as Mali, Kenya, and Nigeria, which have experienced a legacy of colonialism, exhibit similar integrative shaming cultures. Imprisonment in these societies is often associated with slavery, fostering a collective responsibility to reintegrate offenders into society rather than perpetuating stigmatization.

Furthermore, the renowned Australian comparative criminologist John Braithwaite argues that stigmatization is counterproductive and fuels reoffending. Finland’s success can be attributed, in part, to its ability to recognize the basic human needs of offenders and ex-offenders, thus eliminating a significant barrier to their successful reintegration.

The Road Ahead for South Africa:

As South Africa grapples with the staggering rates of recidivism, experts urge a reevaluation of the rehabilitation paradigm. Drawing inspiration from Finland’s transformative approach, the South African Department of Correctional Services can adopt strategies rooted in conflict transformation and the recognition of offenders’ fundamental human needs.

South African academic Gavin Bradshaw emphasizes the effectiveness of integrative approaches in addressing deep-rooted societal conflicts. By acknowledging the basic human needs of ex-offenders, South Africa can pave the way for a significant reduction in recidivism rates.


The striking disparity in recidivism rates between South Africa and Finland underscores the importance of reimagining criminal justice systems worldwide. While South Africa grapples with systemic challenges andthe pressing need for comprehensive reform, Finland offers a shining example of a nation that has successfully tackled the issue of reoffending. By prioritizing dignity, reintegration, and an inclusive approach, Finland has managed to create an environment where ex-offenders have a real chance at rebuilding their lives.

As South Africa contemplates its path forward, it is crucial to recognize the lessons embedded within Finland’s success story. By implementing policies that address inequality, poverty, and unemployment, South Africa can create an environment conducive to rehabilitation and reintegration. Moreover, shifting the narrative from punitive measures to a focus on restoring dignity and providing opportunities for ex-offenders can break the cycle of recidivism.

The road ahead may be challenging, but it is not insurmountable. By embracing a more humane and comprehensive approach to criminal justice, South Africa has the potential to transform the lives of countless individuals and create a safer, more inclusive society.

In the pursuit of a better future, South Africa must draw inspiration from the Finnish model, adapt it to its unique context, and forge a path towards a society where the statistics of recidivism no longer haunt its endeavors. It is time to rewrite the narrative and empower those who seek redemption and a second chance.

Work in SA Jobs

Leave a Comment